The Move
Sign in

New build vs established

The new-build case isn't a slogan — it's a number. Depreciation, the negative-gearing position holding through the Budget-2026 changes, stamp duty and CGT, modelled side-by-side against an equivalent established property on your buyer's own assumptions.

Compare the pair
  • Same price
  • Same income
  • Same borrowing
  • Same growth
One difference
$118,115
more wealth
with new property over a 10-year hold
Your inputs
$750,000

Slider 400k–2m; typical Australian investor band.

VIC
37%

ATO 2026–27 brackets, Stage 3 settings.

20%

5–40%; balance is borrowed.

6.50%

Investor loan, interest-only, current market.

4.20%

State median: 4.2% (CoreLogic).

7.0%

Conservative national long-run avg.

10 years
Results
After-tax wealth at year 10
New property
$471,235
Established
$353,120
Negative gearing
+$15,360 / yr 1

New property keeps the loss-offset tax shield; established loses it from Budget night. The gap appears in cash flow every year of the hold.

Depreciation benefit
+$11,250 / yr 1

Division 40 plant & equipment deductions only apply to new properties. Established stock gets Division 43 capital works only — about half the first-year shield. Deductions also reduce the CGT cost base at sale.

Capital gains tax at sale
$162,185 vs $114,539
New property via discount · Established via indexation · -$47,646 to new property

New property picks the cheaper of 50% discount and indexation. Established loses the discount post-2027 and is taxed via indexation only, with accumulated rental losses reducing the gain. Depreciation claimed during ownership reduces the cost base for both.

Stamp duty (VIC)
+$29,250

Victoria assesses off-the-plan investor duty on land value at contract — typically 30–40% of the finished property value. The state's largest single concession to OTP buyers.

Total tax cost over hold
$25,675 vs $114,539
CGT at sale − cumulative NG tax shield · +$88,865 to new property

Established's lower CGT at sale isn't a real saving — its rental losses had no in-year value because NG is quarantined. New property uses those losses every year as a tax shield, so the only fair comparison is total tax across the whole hold. Negative numbers mean the investor banked more in NG refunds than CGT takes back at sale.

This is an estimate, not credit advice or a loan pre-qualification. It does not state what you can borrow or whether you'll be approved. Confirm with a licensed broker before relying on it.